|
INTERVIEW with "Dow Jones Newswires"
(Berlin, Germany)
http://www.dowjones.com
Full Interview by Chris Reiter
Topic:
The European High Tech Job Market
July
2001 publication
with
ART's Managing Director
Interview Date: 5 July, 2001:
Question 1: How do you see the
European labor market for the technology industry at the moment?
Answer: "Clearly the effects of the lower earnings
reports and the recent layoffs at big wireless and networking equipment
companies are having a ripple effect across many sectors of the
European high tech economy. Many smaller, single product, firms in the
wireless, IT and software sectors that supply those large firms in the
telecom and networking fields are particularly vulnerable, because they
are seeing a delay in orders. If they cannot retool their products for
other large enterprise customer bases, such as banking, government,
automotive, foods, chemicals, or pharmaceuticals, or if their current
sales directors and marketing managers do not have contacts in these
potentially more promising sectors, then these firms might see harder
times. There are slowdowns or layoffs in electronics manufacturing,
semiconductors and in the capital equipment firms that supply these
industries. This is what has already happened in the United States. In
Asia and Latin America layoffs are also beginning. The main difference
between the European and US high tech sectors for the past few years is
that European firms have been much more oriented to telecomms,
telecomms and more telecomms, while a lot of the US high tech boom was
oriented to the internet companies. But a person could buy just so many
mobile phones or visit just so many nearly identical websites before
stock markets and consumers would bring reality to high tech stock
prices and cause layoffs or closures. The layoffs are just starting,
and they will go on for some months, but actually, there are so many
opportunities for technological growth and expansion in Europe that
things should not get all that horrible. I think that what we're mostly
dealing with is overcapacity. In some cases, it's a matter of
technological gaps between product innovation and very costly
infrastructural inabilities to rapidly to deploy them. And then there's
a general disenchantment with tech stocks, which sadly was the result
of a few problem companies spoiling it for the many good and promising
companies."
Question 2: Has there been a
significant change since a year ago? Are companies doing less hiring?
Answer: "Last year, we were seeing endless optimism
and rapidly inflating salary expectations, as good managers could find
plenty of high paying jobs at startups, at telecommunications equipment
firms, at telecommunications carriers, at software companies, computer
companies, network equipment companies, IT service companies and
internet companies. And they felt very positive about their stock
options. Everyone was hiring. A lot of people were talking about IPO's
and making a lot of money. But too many companies were relying on the
same five or ten big customers. This was an unsustainable and risky
focus. Now, a lot of European managers are going back to the idea that
stock options mean little and they are seeking financially stable
companies. Unfortunately, just when Europe was developing cadres of
high tech managers for startup companies, the recent failures and
downturns are causing many to lose faith and to seek refuge back in
the larger companies that usually provide fewer opportunities and are
much more frustrating environments for people who do best in
entrepreneurial, unbureaucratic companies."
Question 3: With the many job
cuts by tech companies and the decline in value of stock-option
packages, are there more people available? Are there more people
looking for jobs? Is it easier to lure people away?
Answer: "There are a lot more people looking for jobs.
We are seeing nearly a 100% increase in applications to our firm from
European candidates. It is not just people seeking better
opportunities, but people who have been laid off or who are about to be
laid off, either at large corporations or at smaller firms that are
losing their financing or customers. We just heard from one outstanding
candidate today who said that his company is going to lay off 65% of
their staff and they will be closing sales offices in several western
European countries. It is easier to interest candidates in exciting
career opportunities because they are so scarce, but sometimes in a bad
economy people are afraid to leave mediocre jobs because they are
concerned about giving up a 'known' for an 'unknown.' By its nature,
every new job entails a certain degree of risk, so people tend to be
very cautious. That is fine with us, because regardless of the economy
or the candidate's status, we always encourage our candidates to
carefully scrutinize our client-companies. In our contracts with our
client-companies we actually oblige them to state all known negatives
or possible negatives to our candidates before they take their job. And
we always encourage our candidates to "interview the company" as
carefully as companies interview candidates."
Question 4: As a recruitment
company have you seen a drop off in requests from employers? Has it
changed your business?
Answer: "Actually, we have seen a significant increase
in requests from employers in Europe, or from companies in other regions
seeking executives and managers for their operations in Europe. This is
largely the cumulative result of years of recruiting dynamic managers
in Europe and from getting repeat business from our clients,
particularly those that need to readjust their management team for slow
markets. Because our practice areas stretch across many different
sectors, job disciplines and regions, we are able to offer our clients
candidates with skills, contacts and knowledge that they will need to
reposition themselves or to become more efficient. And when the
European economy is slowing, we are able to provide candidates to firms
wishing to move into other world markets, such as North America, Latin
America, Asia, Africa, or the Middle East. Even Eastern European
countries -- particularly the countries that are in NATO or that are
candidates to join NATO or the European Union -- are potentially
fertile grounds for European companies to move into. There is plenty of
business in Europe and overseas for high tech companies, but without
the right aggressive managers to point to other options, a company can
only sit around waiting for their competitors to move ahead."
"We also are very unusual - perhaps unique in the world - in
that we absolutely refuse to accept retainers or exclusives for any
executive search assignment, even for CEO's. We believe that retainers
are a passé practice that essentially forces the client to pay
in advance and passively take whatever candidates they are given -- a
recipe for bad feelings and a sloppy way to make a top level hire. We
are so confident of our candidates' abilities to stand on their own
merits against our competitors' candidates, that we are essentially
willing to risk our time, money, labor and resources 'free of charge'
in the expectation that our clients will want to hire our candidates.
Companies love that there is virtually no risk in talking to us or to
our candidates. Our success-orientation particularly is attractive in
slow economies, when a hiring manager can get in trouble for giving
large retainers to a search firm that has not even produced one
candidate to evaluate, that won't allow its client to see candidates
from other firms, and that often takes months to, as they say 'complete
a search,' which to them means to produce a handful of candidates to
fulfill their obligations, and not necessarily to find the right
candidate or the best candidate. In one search that we're doing right
now, for example, we were able to identify seven top candidates for a
European Managing Director position at a US software firm within two
weeks, and our client will not have to pay our fees unless they find
that our candidates are better than all others that they choose to
interview. Good economy or slow economy, it's no wonder that companies
would find our system attractive for their executive management hires."
Question 5: How are you active
in the European tech market? What kind of companies does your company
work for?
Answer: "Our clients are large multinationals,
progressive medium sized companies and high growth startup firms. We
are very active in the European technology market, but we fill a
special and valuable niche for our European client companies. Our
specialty is finding European upper level and middle level managers
whose management style is what might be called "Silicon Valley"
management style. These are people who think as Europeans on a
pan-European basis. In fact, for them, business in Europe, Asia, North
America or other regions, is all treated equally: as tremendous
opportunities. They are not captives of their own traditional national
business cultures or prejudices. They might be rare now, but we see
them as what will have to be the standard for European business
executives in the 21st Century.
"These are people who are natural born independent spirits
who are very self-motivating and who do not work best in huge
bureaucratic organizations. They are the European entrepreneurs who
could be tomorrow's billionaires. These candidates are perfectly fluent
in English and usually in one or more languages, and they work well
with people from different countries and they know how to build
international organizations.
"We do not want to be a search firm for candidates who
really rather work for the rest of their lives at large state-owned
companies or massive private companies that are so slow as to seem like
state-run companies. We do not recruit candidates who spend most of
their work days dreaming of their next or last vacation rather than on
how they could build value into their careers by being at the right
company.
"We specialize in 'risk takers.' They are people who believe
in themselves and in their abilities to motivate their team to do great
things. These candidates can be relatively hard for most search firms
in Europe to find, but they know where to find us and we know where to
find them. So when, for example, a multi-billion dollar British
electronics company needed an entrepreneurial executive who could help
change their manufacturing, financial, and supply chain culture from
the inside, they came to us. When a medium-sized German semiconductor
equipment maker needed what they called an "American style" CFO to help
lead them in mergers and acquisitions activities, they came to us. When
a French semiconductor startup company needed someone with "world
class" business culture to help move their corporate headquarters to
America, they knew to come to us. When a top Finnish telecom company
needed someone for China, they came to us. When a Korean financial
software firm needed a European Sales Director with contacts in London,
Zurich and Frankfurt, they came to us. When a Swiss IT Services company
needed a President, they came to us. When a famous Dutch consumer
electronics corporation needed an R&D Director and Operations
Managers for key product lines, they came to us. When a London-based
wireless carrier needed a CEO for a Latin American startup division,
they came to us. When a Belgian software company was looking for an
entrepreneurial Country Manager for expansion into Poland, they came to
us. When a French wireless content startup company needed a European
Managing Director who had contacts with the highest level executives at
the major European telecommunications carriers, they came to us. And
fast rising e-commerce companies in the UK, the Netherlands, Sweden,
Italy and Spain, for example, knew to come to us for CEO's, COO's,
CIO's, Finance, Sales or Marketing heads.
"To make a long story short: our clients in Europe are those
large companies that know that they must immediately take the steps to
de-bureaucratize themselves in order to really source the potential of
their employees and be competitive, and those small and medium sized
European companies that need experienced executives to help them become
tomorrow's large multinationals."
|